Will Rising CO₂ Help Fire-Adapted Shrubs Survive Drought? New Research Says Probably Not
Maya Zomer, postdoctoral researcher, is the lead author of a new paper in Tree Physiology examining whether elevated atmospheric CO₂ can protect post-fire seedlings against drought stress in Mediterranean shrublands. Her research was completed as part of her dissertation at the Desertification Research Center (CIDE-CSIC) in Valencia, Spain.
The Study
In fire-prone Mediterranean landscapes, many plants rely on germinating from a seed bank after fire, which is known as post-fire seeding. In their first summer, these seedlings face high risk of drought mortality. As climate change intensifies both drought and fire activity, a key open question is whether rising atmospheric CO₂ might offset some of that stress.
Higher CO₂ is known to improve water-use efficiency in plants, leading to the hypothesis that future CO₂ conditions could act as a buffer against drought. Maya and her co-authors set out to rigorously test this idea in five Mediterranean shrub species, spanning both non-resprouting seeders (which regenerate exclusively by seed) and resprouting seeders (which can also resprout after fire). These contrasting strategies are linked to distinct drought-related traits, reflecting the range of variation among post-fire seeders in the region.
Seedlings were grown for eight months under either ambient (~400 ppm) or elevated (~800 ppm) CO₂, then subjected to a carefully controlled progressive drought, which ranged from well-watered to moderate to intense conditions.
Key Findings
- Elevated CO₂ changed plant structure. Plants grown under elevated CO₂ developed denser leaves and, in three species, greater above- and belowground biomass.
- CO₂ did not improve drought stress or modify plant water relations. Elevated CO₂ had no measurable effect on water status or hydraulic behavior under drought, at either the species level or when comparing resprouting vs. non-resprouting groups.
- Resprouting ability shaped how plants responded to drought. Resprouting seeders maintained more stable water potentials as drought intensified, while non-resprouters held higher water potentials under mild and moderate drought but showed steeper declines under severe stress (a pattern independent of CO₂ treatment).
Reflections
This experiment was among the most demanding of Maya's PhD. The team built CO₂ greenhouses from scratch, then weighed and hand-watered 140 large plant pots every day throughout the three-month drought experiment, much of which coincided with the COVID pandemic shutdown in spring 2020.
Overall, findings suggest that elevated CO₂ is unlikely to meaningfully reduce drought risk for post-fire seeders as the climate changes. Moreover, a species' life history strategy, including whether or not it can resprout after fire, is a critical factor in predicting how it will fare in a more fire-prone and drier world.
"Not all plants will respond to rising CO₂ in the same way," said Maya. "We need to account for these differences when modeling plant water use, drought mortality, and fire dynamics under global change."